preparing for iit
jee - My way
prof. smruti r.
sarangi
faculty of computer science and
electrical engg.
iit delhi
march/2018
For many, IIT JEE preparation is
a dream, for many it is a nightmare,
and for many it is something that
they rather never talk about. Given
the mysterious aura surrounding the
big J, I want to clear some of the
doubts and misconceptions in public
interest. However, before I delve
into this topic, some words of
caution and a disclaimer is due.
It is true that I have been a
faculty member in IIT Delhi
(jointly in Computer Science and
Electrical Engineering) for the
last 7 years. However, please note
that I have nothing to do with the
JEE process; I am not privy to the
pattern of the question papers,
neither do I have any interests
whatsoever in coaching institutes
and publishers, or any other
commercial entity connected to
JEE. I am also not claiming that
by following the instructions in
this blog the probability of
qualifying in IIT JEE will
increase. I am an academic with a
Ph.D from the University of
Illinois, USA, a background in
industrial research labs (IBM
Research and Synopsys), and a
B.Tech in Computer Science from
IIT Kharagpur. The reason I write
this blog is because the recent
events with regards to student
suicides in Kota has deeply
touched me, and my feeling is that
if people are better aware of the
nuances of preparing for a
technical career, it might be
beneficial. My employer, IIT
Delhi, does not necessarily
endorse these views, and I am
writing in my personal capacity.
Finally, the views in this blog
are based on how the author
prepared for IIT JEE, they should
not be interpreted as a gold
standard of JEE preparation.
Different people prepare
differently.
Let me start out by saying that
IIT JEE is not the end goal. It is
only a means to an end. The end
should be a satisfying career in
science and engineering. Since
IITs are one of the best
institutes in our country, IIT JEE
has special significance in this
regard. As of 2018, around 1.2
million aspirants write the JEE
Mains exam, roughly 220,000 are
selected for the JEE Advanced
exam, and finally roughly 11,000
candidates are selected. The
success rate for a candidate in
the JEE Advanced exam is roughly
5%. However, note that it is not
necessarily the toughest exam in
the world. The Chinese Gao Kao has
less than 1% acceptance rates, and
so does the Korean CSAT. Of course
comparison is tricky because we
need to define what exactly
a prestigious university
means in these countries.
Nevertheless, we can conclude that
IIT JEE (also known as JEE
Advanced as of today) is a
difficult exam by all means.
In an examination driven system
like India, parents and students
often go to all extents to ensure
success. This can include staying
far away from home in small
apartments and studying for 18
hours a day. This brings with it
psychological problems, lack of
social interaction, and even a
lack of holistic academic
development. We are creating a new
class of IIT JEE specialists who
might not otherwise be very
academically inclined. This is
like making an athlete win a race
using steroids. Once the race is
over, the athlete is back to
square one, and left with the
dangerous after-effects of
steroids. Unfortunately, in this
case more than 95% of the athletes
do not win the race, and this is
even more dangerous.
There is thus a need to opt for a
more reasonable approach here.
Before I share the details of how
I prepared for JEE one more
disclaimer is due. Please note
that if one is interested in a
technical career, then getting a
sound academic background should
be the aim. IITs are no doubt very
good institutions; however, they
are not the only good institutions
in the country. Second, not all
IIT students are super-smart, and
not all students in other colleges
are academically slow. Hence, if a
student does not get a chance to
study in IIT it is no big deal,
the world does not end there. If
someone is genuinely talented and
hard working, life will raise them
to wherever they would have been,
had they gotten an IIT degree.
Basically, focus on studies, be
genuinely interested, and
don't get depressed if you miss
out on IITs.
Let us now start. Unfortunately
till a child is 12-13 years of
age, the parents make the
decisions. Gradually in the teen
years, children take over. Let us
look at classes 1 to 7 first.
In classes 1 to 7, parents have
to take the lead role if they want
their kid to be an IITian in the
future. The most important thing
is to find out whether he/she
genuinely has the aptitude or not.
Here, are some of the traits that
children who are going to be
future IITians possess at an early
age:
1. They are keen observers. They
take a keen interest in things and
are curious.
2. They often have good grades in
their class, and are close to the
top.
3. They are particularly good in
Maths and Science.
If a child is meeting all these
three requirements, then there is
definitely a possiblity. This
needs to be nurtured. Parents can
start exposing the child to a wide
variety of scholastic
environments. Here, are some of
the things that parents can do:
1. Encourage the child to question
anything and everything. They will
develop a scientific temper. No
topic should be taboo.
2. Encourage a regular reading
habit. The child should develop
very good English comprehension
skills. This will help the child
significantly later on.
3. Encourage participation in
different kinds of small
tournaments: spelling bees, chess
tournaments, and kids
olympiads.
4. Put the children in contact
with an adult who can ask them
difficult logical and mathematical
questions. Adults typically ask
questions of the type: with one
eye I see one cow, how many cows
do I see with two eyes? In a
field, we have crows and bulls.
There are 6 heads and 20 legs. How
many crows are there, and how many
bulls are there?
5. The general idea is to create
an academic environment at home
where everything from foreign
affairs, to sports, to politics is
discussed. Children need to take a
keen interest, and they should be
encouraged to speak up, and let
their views known. Shyness in this
case is definitely not a virtue.
These activities will give kids a
very light introduction to the
world of competitive academics
without introducing a lot of
pressure. Even teaching how to
handle stress is also a part of
the training. The idea is to
introduce stressful situations
such as exams very gently and
gradually. Parents need to trust
their instincts or take
professional help when there is a
need.
Class 7 is an important year. It
is like an inflection point
between regular schooling, and
preparation for a higher career.
At this stage, we need to
understand some basic facts about
our education system. School
teachers are not JEE pass outs,
and thus expecting them to train
kids for JEE or something similar
is not wise. Irrespective of the
school, keeping such expectations
is outright impractical. A school
is meant for the masses, and thus
it is incumbent on the parents to
give their kids a little bit extra
if they want more.
In class 7, most students in our
time used to solve problems from
other books that are slightly
harder (mostly mathematics).
Nowadays, people can try books
from other boards particularly the
Singapore board, ICSE, or IB. This
will give a slightly different
exposure.
Let us now come to the three
crucial years, where the main
foundation is made. These are
classes 8, 9, and 10. Let us look
at what future cricket players,
and Olympic athletes are doing at
this age. They begin serious
training. We are not talking of
that rigorous training; however,
the intensity has to gradually
increase. At this age creating a
strong and solid mathematical
foundation is the key. For this,
the school has to give the child
enough time. Moreover, we also
need time for physical exercise,
rest, and social life. Parents
thus need to choose the school
wisely. Having a school that gives
a lot of homework and assignments
is very good, but at least in your
author's view, is not the most
ideal for this purpose. This is
because a typical class has an
overwhelming majority of students
who are not training or aspiring
to make a technical career in top
institutes. Thus the level of
assignments will be low. Given
that our time is limited, it is
necessary to use it more
productively. Note that good
sleep, good nutrition, and ample
physical exercise are vital
requirements throughout the school
years.
In classes 8-10, we can start out
with one hour a day of problem
solving. I would recommend the
following books (note that I have
followed these books myself, and I
have no conflict of interests):
1. Algebra by Hall and Knight
2. OR Algebra by K. P. Basu
3. Geometry by Hall and Stevens
4. Physics for Entertainment,
Perelman
5. Trigonometry by S. L. Loney
It is necessary that the child
meticulously solves all the
problems (cover to cover) over a
3-year period. In terms of mental
stress, this is nothing. This is
being done over and above the
school curriculum. If a child is
able to solve the problems in
these books, then the school exams
are a piece of cake -- it is like
Virat Kohli playing blind-folded.
Note that if the child is facing
some difficulty a study group will
definitely help. However, if there
is a lot of difficulty, then there
is no point in forcing the child.
In the teen years, children should
have a significant say in what
they want to do.
Let us move ahead assuming that
the child is able to coast along
easily. Starting from class 9, it
is time to look at the Regional
Mathematics Olympiad (RMO). There
are many Olympiads today. However,
the original RMO, and INMO (Indian
National Maths Olympiad) are the
ones that are of importance. Each
RMO problem takes hours to solve.
It is very important that early
on, children develop the habit of
just sitting, looking at the sky,
and thinking. This is a vital
skill that is required to do
Science and Engineering. At this
age, we want children to think as
much as possible. Maths olympiads
precisely give them this
opportunity. Subsequently, if the
child is able to do well in the
olympiads it is great. Even
otherwise, the experience is worth
it.
By the end of class 10, children
who have been following these
methods should have developed
sophisticated thinking abilities.
They should be far ahead of their
peers, and also have advanced
reading and comprehension skills.
If this has not happened, and the
class 10 board marks are low, then
clearly we are not going in the
right direction. It might be wise
to change tracks.
Let us now move to the crux years
-- class 11 and 12 -- assuming
that all is going well. Here
again, we don't have to spend long
18 hour days far away from home.
Till now the approach has been to
proceed slowly yet steadfastly.
In classes 11 and 12, the
author strongly discourages
gruelling coaching sessions far
away from home. Again these are
personal views, and are very
strongly influenced by reports in
the popular press regarding the
prevailing situation. Stressful
situations that can have a long
term psychological impact are to
be avoided at all costs.
The aim is to develop a love for
academics, and not treat JEE as
simply a competition where one
needs to win by hook or crook. The
author himself has not taken a lot
of coaching other than 4 hours a
week with a great Maths teacher,
Prof. Kiran Das (from
Kharagpur). Students can
attend coaching sessions. Most of
these are also beneficial, as long
as they don't test human limits.
Parents need to ensure that kids
are not getting unduly
pressurised, and are not at a risk
of developing mental or physical
problems. Again whenever there is
a doubt professional help should
be taken.
Here is my take on these years. In
class 11, students have to solve
very difficult problems.This will
create the necessary background.
They need to exercise their mental
muscles as much as possible. This
investment will continue to bear
fruits even after 50 years.
I would suggest the following
books. Ideally, all the problems
need to be solved -- not mentally,
but by writing out the solution on
a piece of paper. The author read
from these books (again no
conflict of interest).
1. Problems in General Physics, I.
E. Irodov (VERY IMPORTANT)
2. Concepts of Physics, H. C.
Verma
3. Physics by Resnick, Walker, and
Haliday
4. All the math books by S. L.
Loney, and Piskunov
5. Organic Chemistry (Morrison and
Boyd)
The author has unfortunately
forgotten about the books that he
used for inorganic and physical
chemistry. The general rule of
thumb for choosing a book is that
it should be an international best
seller -- a widely respected
classical text. In specific,
the author is a great fan of
Russian books. Sadly, many great
classics from Mir publishers are
not available today.
In addition, students can
subscribe to test prep. services
like what FITJEE, Apex, and
Brilliant used to be in yester
years. Most of these
services have regular tests. This
is a good idea because the
students get an idea of their
relative standing. These tests set
the expectation and make things
very predictable.
Class 12 is the year when students
need to gradually transition from
fundamental building to exam
preparation. Once the students
have covered the syllabus, and
have finished solving most of the
problems from the aforementioned
books, they can start writing mock
exams with old question papers.
Such simulated exams, will help
reduce the stress that students
shall feel in an actual exam hall.
Finally, the big day arrives. The
students hopefully will be well
prepared academically and
psychologically to take the exam.
All the best !!!
Note that in this entire blog, I
have tried to outline a method
that is slow, gradual, and
compassionate. Instead of a
gruelling 2-year training package,
an effort has been made to
create layers of knowledge much
before the student appears for the
JEE exam. The entire focus is to
build mental muscles slowly and
gradually, avoid using academic
steroids, and simultaneously
preserve the love for
academics.